White personalized tooth fairy pillow with pom pom detail held by a child in a cream dress with gold polka dots.
White personalized tooth fairy pillow with pom pom detail held by a child in a cream dress with gold polka dots.

A Tooth Fairy Tradition

Handcrafted pillows to celebrate every lost tooth.
Create Your Tooth Fairy Pillow
Smiling toddler wearing a yellow linen birthday crown, sitting on a white play mat with another child in the background.
Smiling toddler wearing a yellow linen birthday crown, sitting on a white play mat with another child in the background.

Crown Their Moments

From birthdays to dress-up, crowns they’ll treasure forever.
Shop Crowns

THERE'S MAGIC IN YOUR MOMENTS

Beautiful linen keepsakes and custom gifts to make every milestone magical.

Shop by Collection

Handmade tooth fairy pillows shaped like a tooth with pockets and tiny mice, displayed with pastel bunting
Tooth Fairy Pillow
Smiling child wearing a white linen birthday crown in a balloon-filled celebration scene
Birthday Crowns
Neutral linen crib bedding styled in a white nursery with cozy blankets and a modern crib
Linen Crib Bedding

Keepsakes That Become Memories

“

We're ready for the tooth fairy! And so relieved I don't have to try and sneak into my kids' room...just pop on the doorknob and you're all set. Genius! Thanks for a cute keepsake that we'll use for all our kids :)

“

Beautiful packaging and an even more beautiful product! These will be last keepsakes in our family for years to come!

“

Nice quality and fits my normal nursing pillow! And such a sweet personal hand written message with it!

“

This is such a darling tooth holder! My daughter had her first tooth extracted and the tooth fairy left this for her for when she loses other teeth. It’s beautifully made and something we can use for years to come!

“

This is such a special way to remember my mom ... through her handwriting. I love it!

Jordan
Karissa
Maggie
Melissa
Sarah
pink reusable party cracker

Say it with Love

Make Memories More Meaningful with Customizable Party Crackers for Holidays and Celebrations.

Explore More
Handcrafted with Love, Inspired by Motherhood

Handcrafted with Love, Inspired by Motherhood

Madly Wish was born from a mother’s love with a desire to create something special, something that wouldn’t just fill a nursery but would become part of your family’s story.

Every handcrafted keepsake, from our linen crib bedding to personalized birthday crowns, custom tooth fairy pillows, and heartfelt embroidered gifts, is made with care and designed to be cherished for generations. Our linen gifts and childhood keepsakes celebrate the magic of growing up, turning everyday moments into treasured memories.

Read Our Story